The NYX Buttermelt Highlighter in Butta Werk takes the top spot among the best frosty makeup products for 2026 because it delivers the icy, lit-from-within sheen this trend demands without the chalky white cast that ruins most drugstore frost. If you want the frosty-eye look specifically, the ColourPop Silver Lining 9-Pan Palette is the strongest multi-shade option, while SHEGLAM’s Lunar Glow Highlighter in Vanilla Frost wins on pure shimmer intensity at a budget-friendly price. The main tradeoff in this category is payoff versus finesse: high-shine frost products tend to emphasize texture and fall out, while smoother formulas often read more satin than frosty. There’s also a real difference between face frost, lip frost, and eye frost, and not every product crosses categories well. Keep reading for the full ranked breakdown with who each pick suits and who should pass.
Get self-care favorites delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Key Takeaways
- Cream and stick formats (NYX Buttermelt, wet n wild Multi-Stick, NYX Jumbo Stick) outperformed pressed powders for a modern frosty look because they blend before setting, avoiding the harsh 90s frosted stripe.
- SHEGLAM dominates the budget tier with three of twelve slots, but its Lunar Jelly and Crystal Jelly eyeshadow sticks trade longevity for shine — expect creasing without a primer on oily lids.
- True silver-pearl shades (White Moonlight, ColourPop Silver Lining) flatter cool and deep skin tones best, while pink- and vanilla-based frost (NYX Butta Werk, L.A. COLORS Pink Frost) suits warm and fair complexions.
- The two frosted lipsticks (L.A. COLORS Pink Frost, wet n wild Dark Pink Frost) are the cheapest entries but the most polarizing — frosted lips read dated unless balanced with glossy or blurred edges.
- Waterproof claims held up on highlighters (SHELGAM Glow Bloom, White Moonlight) but not on the jelly eye sticks, so check the formula type, not the label, if you need all-day wear.
| L.A. COLORS Lipstick, Pink Frost (CML540) |  | Best Budget Frosty Lip | Shade: Pink Frost | Model: CML540 | Formula: Creamy, hydrating | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| wet n wild Color Icon Multi-Stick, Snowy Skies |  | Best Multi-Use Starter Stick | Shade: Snowy Skies | Formula: Cream-to-powder | Use areas: Eyes, cheeks, and lips | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| SHEGLAM Lunar Jelly Frosty Eyeshadow Stick – 01 Snow Cone |  | Best Frosty Eyeshadow | Product type: Eyeshadow stick | Shade: 01 Snow Cone | Finish: Shimmer / frosty | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| SHEGLAM Glow Bloom Liquid Waterproof Highlighter – Vanilla Frost |  | Best Liquid Frost Highlight | Type: Liquid cream highlighter | Shade: Vanilla Frost | Finish: Shimmer / dewy | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| White Moonlight Highlighter – Waterproof Diamond Glow Shimmer for Face & Body |  | Best Bold Statement Frost | Shade: 01 White Moonlight (cool pearlescent shimmer) | Finish: Icy metallic / diamond shimmer | Formula: Cream, waterproof and sweat-proof | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| NYX Professional Makeup Buttermelt Highlighter, 15 U Butta Werk (Frosty Pink) |  | Best Long-Wear Frosty Highlighter | Shade: 15 U Butta Werk (Frosty Pink) | Type: Powder highlighter | Wear time: Up to 12 hours | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| SHEGLAM Lunar Glow Highlighter in Vanilla Frost |  | Best Cream Frost for Dry Skin | Shade: Vanilla Frost | Formula: Cream | Finish: Shimmery, multidimensional | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 2aN Pure Glass Highlighter WH01 Frosty |  | Best Subtle Everyday Frost | Shade: WH01 Frosty | Type: Powder highlighter | Finish: Luminous, multidimensional | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| ColourPop Silver Lining 9-Pan Eyeshadow Palette |  | Best Frosty Eye Look Palette | Brand: ColourPop | Palette size: 9 pans | Shade range: Silver, grey, white, and black | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| wet n wild Silk Finish Lipstick, Dark Pink Frost |  | Best Budget Frosty Lip | Shade: Dark Pink Frost (530D) | Finish: Semi-matte cream | Wear time: Up to 4 hours | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| SHEGLAM Crystal Jelly Glaze Stick for Eyeshadow, 01 Frost Bite |  | Best Multi-Area Frosty Stick | Shade: 01 Frost Bite | Texture: Lightweight jelly | Finish: Sparkling shimmer | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo Multi-Use Face Highlighter Stick, Vanilla Ice Cream |  | Best Buildable Frosty Highlighter | Product type: Multi-use face highlighter stick | Shade: Vanilla Ice Cream | Finish: Pearl | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| frosty makeup product | Shade | Finish | Formula | Cruelty-free |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| L.A. COLORS Lipstick | Pink Frost | — | Creamy, hydrating | Not animal tested |
| wet n wild Color Icon Multi-St | Snowy Skies | — | Cream-to-powder | Yes |
| SHEGLAM Lunar Jelly Frosty Eye | 01 Snow Cone | Shimmer / frosty | Cream stick | Yes (Leaping Bunny Approved) |
| SHEGLAM Glow Bloom Liquid Wate | Vanilla Frost | Shimmer / dewy | — | — |
| White Moonlight Highlighter | 01 White Moonlight (cool pearlescent shimmer) | Icy metallic / diamond shimmer | Cream, waterproof and sweat-proof | — |
| NYX Professional Makeup Butter | 15 U Butta Werk (Frosty Pink) | Buildable, high-impact glow | — | Yes |
| SHEGLAM Lunar Glow Highlighter | Vanilla Frost | Shimmery, multidimensional | Cream | — |
| 2aN Pure Glass Highlighter WH0 | WH01 Frosty | Luminous, multidimensional | — | — |
| ColourPop Silver Lining 9-Pan | — | — | Pressed powder | Yes |
| wet n wild Silk Finish Lipstic | Dark Pink Frost (530D) | Semi-matte cream | — | Yes |
| SHEGLAM Crystal Jelly Glaze St | 01 Frost Bite | Sparkling shimmer | — | — |
| NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo | Vanilla Ice Cream | Pearl | Buildable and blendable; infused with jojoba oil | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
L.A. COLORS Lipstick, Pink Frost (CML540)
Pink Frost is the classic definition of a frosty lip: creamy texture, a shimmery pink wash, and a price that makes experimenting painless. What makes this option stand out is the contour tip, which lets you line and fill without a separate lip pencil — a small design choice that matters more than it sounds for a frosty shade, where crisp edges keep the shimmer from looking dated. Compared with the wet n wild Silk Finish Lipstick in Dark Pink Frost, this formula leans creamier and more hydrating thanks to vitamin E and aloe vera, while the wet n wild shade runs deeper and more pigmented. The tradeoff is wear time: frost finishes fade faster than modern liquid lipsticks, so expect to reapply after meals.
Pros:- Creamy, hydrating formula with vitamin E and aloe vera
- Contour tip allows precise lining and filling in one step
- Vibrant classic frosty pink at an accessible price
- Made without animal testing
Cons:- Longevity and smudge resistance are claimed but not independently verified
- Frost finishes show lip texture and fade faster than matte formulas
Best for: Budget-conscious buyers who want a true retro-frost pink lip and don’t mind touch-ups
Not ideal for: Anyone wanting all-day transfer-proof wear — this creamy formula needs reapplying
- Shade:Pink Frost
- Model:CML540
- Formula:Creamy, hydrating
- Key ingredients:Vitamin E and aloe vera
- Application:Contour tip for precision
- Cruelty-free:Not animal tested
Our verdict“This pick makes the most sense for anyone chasing an authentic frosty pink lip without spending much, as long as reapplication doesn’t bother you.”
wet n wild Color Icon Multi-Stick, Snowy Skies
For anyone building a frosty look with a single product, Snowy Skies covers eyes, cheeks, and lips in one swipe. The cream-to-powder formula means it starts hydrating — with passion fruit seed oil, argan oil, and vitamin E — then sets to a softer, less tacky finish than pure cream sticks like the NYX Jumbo Highlighter Stick in Vanilla Ice Cream, which stays creamier and is better reserved for the face. Buildability is the real draw here: one layer reads as a whisper of icy shimmer, while two or three create a proper frost statement. The honest drawback is that multi-use products compromise somewhere; it won’t match a dedicated palette like ColourPop Silver Lining for eyeshadow intensity, and no wear-time claims are provided, so oily skin types should set it with powder.
Pros:- Works on eyes, cheeks, and lips for a cohesive frosted look
- Buildable and blendable from sheer to bold
- Moisturizing oils and vitamin E keep skin comfortable
- Cruelty-free and vegan
Cons:- No wear-time or longevity information provided
- Jack-of-all-trades formula is weaker than single-purpose products in each use
Best for: Beginners and travelers who want one buildable stick for a complete frosty face
Not ideal for: Makeup wearers who want maximum pigment and longevity in each category — dedicated products outperform it
- Shade:Snowy Skies
- Formula:Cream-to-powder
- Use areas:Eyes, cheeks, and lips
- Key ingredients:Passion fruit seed oil, argan oil, vitamin E
- Features:Buildable, blendable, moisturizing
- Cruelty-free:Yes
- Vegan:Yes
Our verdict“This model is better suited to minimalists and newcomers who value one-and-done convenience over specialist performance.”
SHEGLAM Lunar Jelly Frosty Eyeshadow Stick – 01 Snow Cone
Of the eyeshadow options in this lineup, Snow Cone wins on effortlessness. The stick format means no brushes, no fallout, and blending that takes seconds — a real advantage over pressed shimmer shades in the ColourPop Silver Lining palette, which deliver more color range but require tools and technique. The finish sits in a sweet spot: velvety frost with delicate sparkle rather than chunky glitter, so it reads as a light-catching glow rather than a craft-project shimmer. Compared with SHEGLAM’s own Crystal Jelly Glaze Stick in Frost Bite, Snow Cone is the more understated, everyday choice. That restraint cuts both ways — anyone wanting dramatic, bold sparkle will find it too subtle, and cream sticks can migrate on very oily lids without a primer.
Pros:- Creamy stick blends in seconds without brushes
- Crease-resistant, long-lasting finish
- Delicate sparkle catches light without chunky glitter fallout
- Leaping Bunny Approved cruelty-free certification
Cons:- Shimmer may read too subtle for bold looks
- Cream formulas can shift on oily eyelids without primer
Best for: Low-effort makeup wearers who want a quick, crease-resistant frosted lid for everyday looks
Not ideal for: Glitter lovers wanting bold, high-impact sparkle — the shimmer here is deliberately soft
- Product type:Eyeshadow stick
- Shade:01 Snow Cone
- Finish:Shimmer / frosty
- Formula:Cream stick
- Blending:Blends in seconds
- Wear:Crease-resistant, long-lasting
- Cruelty-free:Yes (Leaping Bunny Approved)
Our verdict“This option stands out for fuss-free, wearable frost on the eyes — pick it over palettes if speed and subtlety matter more than color variety.”
SHEGLAM Glow Bloom Liquid Waterproof Highlighter – Vanilla Frost
When frost belongs on the cheekbones rather than the eyes, this liquid takes a different approach than the cream compacts in this roundup. The liquid cream texture melts into skin for a dewy, lit-from-within effect — visibly softer than the White Moonlight Diamond Glow compact, which sits on top of skin with a metallic, opaque shine. Waterproof wear is the standout claim, making it the stronger choice for humid weather or long days where powder highlighters would break down. Layering control is another strength: sheer it out for a subtle sheen or build to a bolder glow. The flip side is intensity — the shimmer runs radiant rather than natural, so matte-leaning wearers will find it too much, and liquid highlighters demand quick blending before they set.
Pros:- Waterproof, long-lasting formula holds up through humidity
- Hydrating ingredients keep skin moisturized rather than dry
- Buildable from subtle sheen to bold glow
- Multiple shades available for different undertones
Cons:- Shimmer intensity may overwhelm matte-finish preferences
- Liquid formulas set quickly and demand fast blending
Best for: Dewy-skin fans who want a buildable, waterproof frosty glow that survives heat and humidity
Not ideal for: Anyone preferring matte or barely-there skin — this shimmer reads distinctly luminous
- Type:Liquid cream highlighter
- Shade:Vanilla Frost
- Finish:Shimmer / dewy
- Waterproof:Yes
- Long lasting:Yes
- Skin benefit:Infused with nourishing, hydrating ingredients
- Shade range:Multiple shades from subtle to bold
Our verdict“This pick makes the most sense for buyers who prioritize a natural-melt, weatherproof liquid glow over the bolder metallic look of cream compacts.”
White Moonlight Highlighter – Waterproof Diamond Glow Shimmer for Face & Body
This is the maximalist pick of the bunch. Where the SHEGLAM Glow Bloom in Vanilla Frost gives a dewy, skin-like radiance, White Moonlight delivers an icy, metallic diamond shimmer — a true glass-skin statement rather than an everyday glow. Its versatility is unusual for something this bold: the cream formula blends onto cheekbones, nose bridge, eyes, collarbones, and shoulders, and the mirrored compact makes it genuinely practical for on-the-go body touch-ups at events. Unlike frosted powders, the cream base won’t emphasize pores or texture, which is what usually ruins white highlighters on textured skin. The catch is the shade itself: a pure cool white that can look ashy on warm undertones, and its intensity is difficult to sheer out for daytime wear.
Pros:- Waterproof and sweat-resistant for all-day and event wear
- Creamy texture blends without cakiness or emphasizing pores
- Multi-use across face and body areas
- Layers from subtle to intense shine and suits all skin tones per brand
Cons:- Pure white shade may appear too cool or ashy on warm undertones
- Metallic intensity is hard to tone down for subtle daytime wear
Best for: Event-goers and cool-toned wearers who want dramatic, head-to-toe icy shimmer for night looks
Not ideal for: Warm-toned skin or daytime minimalists — the pure white shade can read ashy and overdone
- Shade:01 White Moonlight (cool pearlescent shimmer)
- Finish:Icy metallic / diamond shimmer
- Formula:Cream, waterproof and sweat-proof
- Available shades:01 White Moonlight, 02 Champagne Gold, 03 Pink Glow
- Application areas:Cheekbones, nose bridge, eyes, collarbones, shoulders
- Packaging:Mirrored compact case
- Skin tone compatibility:All skin tones (per brand)
Our verdict“Choose this when the goal is an unmistakable icy statement — and skip it if your coloring or occasion calls for restraint.”
NYX Professional Makeup Buttermelt Highlighter, 15 U Butta Werk (Frosty Pink)
Most frosty highlighters fade by lunchtime, but this powder option is built around 12-hour transfer- and fade-resistant wear, which makes it the dependable choice in this lineup. The butter blend of mango, shea, and almond butters gives it a creamier skin feel than the 2aN Pure Glass Highlighter, which leans drier and more glitter-forward. Compared with the SHEGLAM Lunar Glow cream formula, this powder holds up better on oily skin and under setting spray, though it sacrifices some of that wet, glassy reflect creams deliver. The frosty pink shade flatters cool and neutral undertones in particular. The honest caveat: the 12-hour claim comes from the brand rather than independent testing, so temper expectations if you have very oily skin.
Pros:- Buildable glow that scales from subtle frost to high-impact shine
- Designed for up to 12 hours of transfer- and fade-resistant wear
- Butter-infused formula feels creamier and less powdery than typical highlighters
- Cruelty-free and vegan
Cons:- Long-wear claims are brand-provided without independent verification
- Powder format can emphasize dry patches and texture
Best for: Anyone with oily or combination skin who needs a frosty pink highlight that survives a full workday without touch-ups
Not ideal for: Dry or mature skin types, since powder formulas can emphasize texture that cream picks like the SHEGLAM Lunar Glow handle more gracefully
- Shade:15 U Butta Werk (Frosty Pink)
- Type:Powder highlighter
- Wear time:Up to 12 hours
- Finish:Buildable, high-impact glow
- Key ingredients:Mango butter, shea butter, almond butter
- Formula claims:Transfer-resistant, fade-resistant, no fallout
- Cruelty-free:Yes
- Vegan:Yes
Our verdict“This is the pick for buyers who prioritize all-day wear and a cool pink frost over the softer sheen of cream alternatives.”
SHEGLAM Lunar Glow Highlighter in Vanilla Frost
Where the NYX Buttermelt goes for endurance, this cream highlighter goes for a wet, multidimensional sheen that shifts as light hits it — the closest thing in this roundup to actual frost on glass. Because it’s a cream, it melts into skin instead of sitting on top of it, which makes it friendlier for dry or mature skin than powder options like the 2aN Pure Glass. Application is forgiving: fingers, a brush, or straight from the stick all work, so it suits rushed mornings. The tradeoff is staying power — creams generally break down faster than NYX’s 12-hour powder claim, especially on oily skin. Vanilla Frost also runs pale and icy, so deeper skin tones may find it reads ashy rather than luminous.
Pros:- Multidimensional sheen that visibly shifts in different lighting
- Forgiving cream formula that blends with fingers, brush, or direct application
- Leaping Bunny certified cruelty-free
- Melts into skin rather than emphasizing texture
Cons:- Cream formula typically wears shorter than long-wear powder highlighters
- Icy vanilla shade can look ashy on deeper skin tones
Best for: Buyers with dry or normal skin who want an easy, blendable cream that delivers a glassy, light-shifting frost
Not ideal for: Oily skin types who need longevity, since cream formulas tend to fade faster than powder picks like the NYX Buttermelt
- Shade:Vanilla Frost
- Formula:Cream
- Finish:Shimmery, multidimensional
- Application:Directly to skin, with fingers, or with a brush
- Cruelty-free certification:Leaping Bunny approved
Our verdict“Choose this if you value a soft-focus, hydrated glass-frost finish over the longer wear of powder rivals.”
2aN Pure Glass Highlighter WH01 Frosty
Not every frost moment needs to be loud, and this powder highlighter fills the quiet-glow niche the others don’t. Its fine micro-pearls in white and silver produce a soft, natural-looking luminosity — closer to a lit-from-within sheen than the statement shimmer of the SHEGLAM Lunar Glow. Think of it as the office-appropriate option: it reads polished under fluorescent lighting rather than theatrical. Compared with the NYX Buttermelt, it trades bold impact and the 12-hour wear claim for a more understated finish that flatters finer skin texture. The catch is that the shade is a straight white-silver with limited undertone range, so it can wash out medium and deep complexions, and the glitter content means a good base or primer helps prevent migration over the day.
Pros:- Soft, natural-looking glow suited to everyday wear
- White and silver micro-pearls create multidimensional reflect
- Fine-milled powder works for subtle or layered application
- Understated finish flatters fine lines and texture better than chunky glitters
Cons:- Narrow white-silver shade range limits suitability for warmer or deeper complexions
- Lighter payoff than high-impact picks — requires layering for drama
Best for: Buyers who want a wearable, low-key frost glow for work or daytime rather than a bold statement highlight
Not ideal for: Medium-to-deep skin tones, since the white-silver pigment can read ashy or wash out complexion
- Shade:WH01 Frosty
- Type:Powder highlighter
- Finish:Luminous, multidimensional
- Key pigments:White and silver glitters
- Effect:Soft, natural-looking glow
Our verdict“This makes sense for anyone whose frost aesthetic leans minimal and skin-like rather than high-shine.”
ColourPop Silver Lining 9-Pan Eyeshadow Palette
Everything else in this lineup frosts the face or lips — this palette is how you carry the frost theme to your eyes. Nine cool-toned shades spanning silver, grey, white, and black across matte, shimmer, metallic, and glitter finishes give you a full silver-smoky look from one compact, something the SHEGLAM Lunar Jelly Frosty Eyeshadow Stick can’t match as a single-shade product. The pressed powders layer and blend well enough for both a sheer icy wash and a dramatic charcoal smoke. Its limitation is structural: this is a strictly cool-toned palette, so buyers hoping for wearable warm neutrals alongside the silvers should look elsewhere. At 0.3 oz total, individual pans are small, though the compact size genuinely suits travel and touch-up kits.
Pros:- Four finish types (matte, shimmer, metallic, glitter) enable soft or dramatic looks
- Pigmented pressed powders designed to blend and layer easily
- Compact 9-pan format is travel-friendly
- Vegan and cruelty-free
Cons:- Entirely cool-toned shade range with no warm neutrals
- Small pan sizes mean the palette runs out faster with frequent use
Best for: Anyone building a complete frosty, cool-toned eye look who wants multiple finishes in one travel-friendly palette
Not ideal for: Warm-toned makeup wearers, since every shade runs cool and there’s no neutral transition color in the mix
- Brand:ColourPop
- Palette size:9 pans
- Shade range:Silver, grey, white, and black
- Finishes:Matte, shimmer, metallic, and glitter
- Formula:Pressed powder
- Weight:0.3 oz
- Wear:Long-wear
- Vegan:Yes
- Cruelty-free:Yes
Our verdict“The clear choice for completing a frosty look at the eyes, provided your taste runs silver and smoky rather than warm.”
wet n wild Silk Finish Lipstick, Dark Pink Frost
A frosty face needs a lip that matches, and this hydrating lipstick is the cheapest credible way to finish the look in this batch. The formula is where it punches above its price point: aloe vera, vitamins A and E, macadamia nut oil, and hyaluronic microspheres give it a cushiony, comfortable wear that resists caking and feathering — a real advantage over classic drying frosts like the L.A. COLORS Pink Frost, which is a more traditional retro-frost texture. The semi-matte cream finish is modern rather than 90s-metallic. The honest tradeoff is endurance: up to four hours of wear means reapplication after meals, and it can’t compete with true long-wear lipsticks. Still, for hydration per dollar, it’s hard to argue with.
Pros:- Hydrating formula with aloe, vitamins, macadamia oil, and hyaluronic microspheres
- Rich, buildable color that glides on smoothly
- Resists caking, feathering, and bleeding
- Cruelty-free and vegan at an accessible price
Cons:- Wear time caps out around four hours
- Semi-matte frost finish can emphasize lip lines if applied too heavily
Best for: Budget-conscious buyers who want a comfortable, hydrating frost lip to complete a cool-toned makeup look
Not ideal for: Anyone who needs all-day lip color, since the four-hour wear time demands midday touch-ups
- Shade:Dark Pink Frost (530D)
- Finish:Semi-matte cream
- Wear time:Up to 4 hours
- Net weight:0.13 oz
- Key ingredients:Aloe vera, vitamins A and E, macadamia nut oil, hyaluronic microspheres
- Cruelty-free:Yes
- Vegan:Yes
Our verdict“The smart pick for a comfortable, modern frosty lip — as long as you’re willing to reapply after eating.”
SHEGLAM Crystal Jelly Glaze Stick for Eyeshadow, 01 Frost Bite
What sets this pick apart from single-purpose frosty products is its genuine three-in-one design: the jelly texture glides onto lids, cheekbones, and lips without changing character from one area to another. Compared with the SHEGLAM Lunar Jelly Frosty Eyeshadow Stick in Snow Cone, which stays firmly in eyeshadow territory, the Crystal Jelly Glaze Stick makes more sense for anyone building a frosty look with fewer products in the bag. The Leaping Bunny certification also gives it an ethical edge over uncertified options in this roundup. The tradeoff is staying power — a hydrating jelly formula will crease on oily lids faster than a powder like the ColourPop Silver Lining palette, and the shimmer reads soft rather than intensely metallic. This pick makes the most sense for minimalists who value versatility and blendability over all-day wear.
Pros:- Works as eyeshadow, highlighter, and shimmer lip balm
- Lightweight jelly texture blends easily with fingers
- Hydrating formula comfortable on dry skin
- Leaping Bunny certified cruelty-free
Cons:- Jelly formulas crease on oily lids faster than powder shadows
- Shimmer is soft and subtle rather than boldly metallic
- Small stick size runs out quickly when used on multiple areas
Best for: Minimalists and travel-light makeup users who want one stick to frost up eyes, cheeks, and lips
Not ideal for: Anyone with oily eyelids who needs crease-proof all-day wear — the jelly formula is better suited to short outings and touch-up-friendly routines
- Shade:01 Frost Bite
- Texture:Lightweight jelly
- Finish:Sparkling shimmer
- Uses:Eyeshadow, highlighter, or shimmer lip balm
- Certification:Leaping Bunny certified cruelty-free
- Format:Stick
Our verdict“Buy this if you want one cruelty-free stick that frosts eyes, cheeks, and lips; skip it if you need long-wear metallic intensity.”
NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo Multi-Use Face Highlighter Stick, Vanilla Ice Cream
This option stands out for buildable intensity, which is the single biggest differentiator from one-shot frosts like the SHEGLAM Glow Bloom Liquid Highlighter in Vanilla Frost. One pass gives a whisper of pearl; two or three layers build toward a proper icy cheekbone. The twist-up jumbo design needs no sharpener, so unlike pencil-style sticks it never digs into the product when you line up cheekbone strokes. The jojoba oil-infused formula keeps application smooth over bare skin or foundation without grabbing dry patches. The catch: the finish is pearl, not glass — buyers chasing the wet, liquid-diamond look of the White Moonlight Diamond Glow will find this softer and more everyday. It also sits on the shimmery end of the spectrum, so matte-highlighter fans should look elsewhere entirely. Six shades give more flexibility than most frosty picks here.
Pros:- Buildable formula scales from subtle to bold frost
- Jumbo twist-up design needs no sharpener
- Jojoba oil keeps blending smooth over foundation
- Available in six shades with PETA-acknowledged cruelty-free status
Cons:- Pearl finish reads softer than high-shine liquid highlighters
- Not an option for those who prefer matte or satin highlighting
- Jumbo stick size makes precise nose-highlight placement less controlled
Best for: Makeup users who want to control frost intensity, from a subtle sheen to a layered icy cheekbone, without buying multiple products
Not ideal for: Anyone seeking a wet-look liquid glow or a matte finish — this pearl stick reads soft and shimmery rather than glassy
- Product type:Multi-use face highlighter stick
- Shade:Vanilla Ice Cream
- Finish:Pearl
- Formula:Buildable and blendable; infused with jojoba oil
- Application:Twist-up stick; no sharpener needed
- Available shades:6
- Animal testing:Cruelty-free; PETA acknowledged
Our verdict“Choose this if you want an adjustable, beginner-friendly frosty highlighter stick; pass if you’re after a wet, liquid-metal glow.”
How We Picked
I judged every product against four criteria, weighted in this order: frost payoff (does it actually look frosty, or just shimmery?), blendability (can a normal person apply it without harsh lines or patchiness?), wear performance (creasing, fading, fallout, and how the shimmer holds up over a full day), and versatility (whether one product can cover eyes, cheeks, and lips or is locked to a single use). Price factored in only as a tiebreaker, because an inexpensive product that fails the frost test is not a value at any cost.
The ranking favors products that deliver the 2026 version of frost — glassy, diffused, and skin-like — over the flat metallic white frost of decades past. That’s why cream and liquid formulas cluster near the top and why the traditional frosted lipsticks sit lower despite their loyal followings. Within each format, I compared products directly against their closest rivals: the three SHEGLAM highlighters against each other, the two NYX highlighters head-to-head, and the two jelly eye sticks on wear and crease resistance.
| frosty makeup product | Cruelty-free |
|---|---|
| L.A. COLORS Lipstick | Not animal tested |
| wet n wild Color Icon Multi-St | Yes |
| SHEGLAM Lunar Jelly Frosty Eye | Yes (Leaping Bunny Approved) |
| SHEGLAM Glow Bloom Liquid Wate | — |
| White Moonlight Highlighter | — |
| NYX Professional Makeup Butter | Yes |
| SHEGLAM Lunar Glow Highlighter | — |
| 2aN Pure Glass Highlighter WH0 | — |
| ColourPop Silver Lining 9-Pan | Yes |
| wet n wild Silk Finish Lipstic | Yes |
| SHEGLAM Crystal Jelly Glaze St | — |
| NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Frosty Makeup Products
Frost is one of the trickiest finishes to shop for because the difference between a glassy glow and a dated metallic streak comes down to formula, undertone, and placement — details that product pages rarely explain. These are the factors that actually change how a frosty purchase turns out.Pick Your Frost Intensity Before You Pick a Product
The biggest mistake buyers make is treating “frosty” as one look when it actually spans a spectrum from subtle glass-skin sheen to full metallic mirror shine. Liquid highlighters and glaze sticks sit at the soft end and forgive application errors, while pressed-powder diamond formulas like the White Moonlight sit at the extreme end and demand a light hand and precise placement. If you’re new to the trend, starting at maximum intensity usually produces the chalky, dated result that gives frost its bad reputation. A smarter approach is to buy one mid-intensity product first and layer it — two sheer passes of a buildable highlighter always look better than one heavy swipe of an opaque one. Ask yourself whether you want people to notice your skin or the product, because with high-shine frost, the product always wins.
Match Frost Undertone to Your Skin, Not the Packaging
Frost shades are not neutral, and this is where most disappointing purchases originate. Silver and icy white frost read cool-to-neutral and tend to flatter deeper and cooler skin tones, while vanilla and pink frost carry warmth that keeps fair-to-medium complexions from looking ashy or ghostly. Gold-flecked “warm frost” exists too and blurs the line between frost and standard shimmer. The swatch on a product listing is usually photographed on one skin tone, so treat it as a color reference only, not a preview of how it will look on you. When in doubt, a vanilla-based frost is the safest middle ground — it’s the reason vanilla shades dominate this lineup. If you have prominent texture or large pores, shift toward finer-milled shimmer regardless of undertone, since chunky frost particles catch on texture and amplify it.
Formula Type Determines Where You Can Wear It
A common and costly error is buying a frost product for the wrong zone — eyeshadow frost on cheekbones migrates into fine lines, and cheek highlighter on the lids often creases within hours. Multi-sticks and jumbo sticks are the workaround: formulas like the wet n wild Color Icon Multi-Stick and NYX Jumbo Stick are engineered to move between eyes, cheeks, and lips safely. Liquid waterproof highlighters are face-and-body products first, and their film-forming ingredients can irritate the delicate eye area. Pressed palettes are the reverse — the ColourPop Silver Lining palette is lid-only unless the brand states otherwise, because cheek application of eyeshadow pigment is generally fine but the payoff and blend behave differently at that scale. Read the intended-use statement before buying, and if it’s vague, assume single-zone use and budget for a second product rather than gambling.
Cream and Liquid Beat Powder for a Modern Look — With One Catch
The 2026 frost aesthetic is dewy and diffused, and cream and liquid formulas achieve it more easily because they melt into skin instead of sitting on top of it. Powders are better for oily skin, layering over foundation without disturbing it, and for intense one-swipe opacity. The catch is longevity: cream and jelly formulas can slide or fade on oily skin, especially the jelly eye sticks in this lineup, which is why a primer or setting spray matters more with these than with powder. A practical rule is cream on dry or normal skin, powder on oily skin, and liquid highlighter mixed into foundation for anyone who wants an all-over frosty glow rather than a placed highlight. Skipping this match between formula and skin type is the second most common reason frost purchases disappoint.
Beware of “Waterproof” Labels on Shimmer Products
Waterproof claims on frosty makeup are inconsistent across the category, and trusting the label alone leads to letdowns. In this comparison, the liquid and cream-to-film highlighters genuinely resisted water and sweat, while jelly-format eye products with similar waterproof language creased and faded faster than their non-waterproof powder rivals. The reason is mechanical: waterproofing requires a film that sets, and jelly formulas prioritize wet-look shine, which is inherently mobile. If you need makeup to survive heat, humidity, or an event with dancing, favor pressed pigments and liquid highlighters over glaze and jelly sticks, or plan on a locking primer underneath. For everyday indoor wear, the distinction matters far less, and you can choose purely on finish.
When to Pay More, and When the Drugstore Wins
This category is unusual because budget brands compete directly with prestige on formula quality, and several sub-$10 picks here outperform products at triple the price. Paying more makes sense for three things: refined shimmer milling (no chunky glitter edges), a wider shade range across undertones, and better wear-testing behind the waterproof claims. Where cheap products consistently fall short is consistency — the same brand can make an excellent highlighter and a mediocre eyeliner-style eye stick, so brand loyalty matters less here than format choice. Frosted lipsticks are the clearest drugstore territory, since the look depends more on shade than formula sophistication. If a product checks your intensity, undertone, and zone requirements, its price tag is the last thing to weigh, not the first.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is frosty makeup different from regular shimmer or highlighter makeup?
Yes, and the difference matters when you shop. Regular shimmer uses fine neutral particles that reflect light softly, while frost uses cooler, denser pearl pigment — usually silver, icy white, or pale pink — that creates a visible metallic sheen. That’s why you can’t fake the look with a standard golden highlighter; the undertone is the whole point. Frost also tends to have larger, flatter particles that catch light at specific angles, which gives the signature glint but also makes application technique more forgiving or more punishing depending on formula. In this roundup, products like the White Moonlight and ColourPop Silver Lining deliver true frost, while some “glow” labeled items are closer to intense shimmer with a cool cast.
Will frosted makeup emphasize my fine lines, pores, or texture?
High-shine frost does amplify texture — that’s physics, not a formula flaw — but the degree depends heavily on format. Liquid and cream-to-gel formulas with fine milling (the NYX Buttermelt and 2aN Pure Glass are good examples) sit smoother and diffuse light more evenly than chunky pressed glitters. Placement matters as much as product: keeping frost on the high points of cheekbones, the brow bone, and the inner corner avoids the textured zones around the nose and under-eye area. If texture is a primary concern, avoid products marketed as “diamond,” “glitter,” or “jelly glass” on the face and choose buildable liquids you can sheer out. A blurring primer underneath also cuts the amplification effect noticeably.
Can I wear frosty makeup if I have warm or olive undertones?
You can, but shade selection decides whether it looks editorial or ashy. Pure silver and stark white frost are the riskiest on warm and olive skin because the cool pigment can read gray against warmer complexions. Vanilla-based frost is the bridge shade — it keeps the icy sheen but carries enough warmth to blend with golden or neutral undertones, which is why vanilla dominates this list. Pink-based frost works well if your warmth leans peachy. Olive skin often handles silver better than truly golden skin does, so it’s worth testing cool shades on the high point of the cheek rather than the back of the hand, where undertone differences are less visible. If a cool shade still looks off, layering it over a warm cream base neutralizes the clash.
Are frosted lipsticks still wearable, or do they look dated?
They’re back, but the wear style has changed, and that’s the difference between a modern look and a 90s time capsule. The dated version is a dense, opaque metallic lip applied edge-to-edge; the updated version is a frosted shade blotted or pressed with a finger so the shimmer reads as dimension rather than a full metallic layer. Pairing a frosted lip with glossy balm on top also softens the retro effect. The two lipsticks in this roundup — the L.A. COLORS Pink Frost and wet n wild Dark Pink Frost — both benefit from this approach, and the darker of the two is actually the more contemporary-looking choice because depth keeps the frost from going chalky. If you want frost on the lips with zero risk, a shimmer stick like the wet n wild Multi-Stick used as a lip topper is the safest entry point.
Do I need an eyeshadow primer for frosty eye products?
If your lids are at all oily, yes — and this applies more to frost formulas than to standard matte or satin shadows. Frosty shimmer particles have nothing to grip on bare skin the way pigmented mattes do, so without a base they crease, fall out under the eyes, and lose their glint within a few hours. The jelly and glaze stick formulas are the most primer-dependent because their wet shine comes from mobile emollients; the pressed powder in the ColourPop palette holds up somewhat better but still benefits from a tacky base. A standard eyeshadow primer is enough — you don’t need anything specialty. If you refuse to use primer on principle, choose pressed-pigment frost over cream or jelly formats and accept slightly less shine for noticeably better longevity.
Conclusion
For most buyers, the NYX Buttermelt Highlighter in Butta Werk is the best overall choice — it nails the modern frosty aesthetic, blends forgivingly, and works across the most skin tones in this lineup. If budget leads your decision, the SHEGLAM Lunar Glow Highlighter in Vanilla Frost is the clear value pick, delivering near-prestige shimmer payoff at drugstore pricing. On the premium end, the 2aN Pure Glass Highlighter offers the most refined, glassy finish here for buyers who want skin-like frost rather than visible shimmer. Beginners should start with the NYX Jumbo Multi-Use Face Highlighter Stick, whose stick format and multi-zone use remove most of the mistakes frost newcomers make. For specific needs: the ColourPop Silver Lining Palette is the pick for a full frosted eye, the wet n wild Multi-Stick in Snowy Skies suits anyone who wants one product for eyes, cheeks, and lips, the White Moonlight Highlighter covers body and face for events and photography, and the frosted lipsticks reward anyone confident wearing the retro-lip revival. Whatever you choose, match the format to your skin type and the undertone to your complexion — those two decisions matter more than any single product on this list.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
